The Shell Game of Corrupted Government Exposed
SB 99: For Whose Benefit?
Publisher's note: This post,by Brian Balfour, was originally published in the in Bad Bill of the Week section of Civitas's online edition.
This week's Bad Bill of the Week is another repeat offender. SB 99, the North Carolina Benefit Corporation Act, is the same piece of legislation dubbed a "Bad Bill" by Civitas in 2011. This year's version is sponsored by Senators Peter Brunstetter (R-Forsyth) and Eleanor Kinnaird (D-Orange).
For starters, the underlying premise of creating a "benefit corporation" is that traditional corporations and companies don't benefit the public. This notion, of course, is ludicrous. As Francis DeLuca noted in the 2011 Bad Bill summary: "A lawful, profitable business, by its very existence, already 'benefits' society...A business, by making a profit, increases the wealth of society and hence the ability of individuals to find employment and increase their standard of living. They also provide products and services that make our lives better."
Moreover, upon reading SB 99 we discover how the state would evaluate whether or not a company is a "benefit corporation." According to the bill, "a benefit corporation shall have as one of its corporate purposes the creation of a general public benefit." The legislation defines "general public benefit" as: "A material positive impact on society and the environment, taken as a whole, as measured by a third-party standard." (Emphasis added.)
This passage provides a major clue suggesting that SB 99 seeks to enforce the activities of companies according to certain standards of environmental impact and sustainability measures. And who provides this "third-party standard?"
A non-profit group called "B-Lab" is the primary third-party evaluator of B-corporations. One of the perks of becoming a B-corporation is joining a network of other companies to take advantage of discounted services provided by other B-corporations (the list of members confirms B-Lab's mission of largely promoting "sustainability" measures). Over time, however, it would not be surprising if B-corporations begin to seek favored tax statuses as well.
Oh, by the way, B-Lab doesn't appear to provide "third-party" approval for B-corporations out of the goodness of their hearts. According to this New York Times article, it can run up to $25,000 for a corporation to join the membership rolls of B-corporations.
What a nice scam for the B-Lab folks: pressure state legislatures to enact laws recognizing B-corporations based upon your approval, then charge for that approval.
If companies want to adjust how they spend their money or their "environmental impact," they should be free to do so and free to contract with consultants to evaluate and improve their efforts. There is no reason why legislation needs to interject itself into this process. It doesn't seem far-fetched to believe that this scheme was cooked up by B-Lab as an effort to use legislative authority to line their pockets. One also should be concerned with the use of legislative muscle to advance often highly questionable "sustainability" measures, as well as the potential for B-corporations to seek government privileges in the future. For these reasons, SB 99 is this week's Bad Bill of the Week.
Go Back
This week's Bad Bill of the Week is another repeat offender. SB 99, the North Carolina Benefit Corporation Act, is the same piece of legislation dubbed a "Bad Bill" by Civitas in 2011. This year's version is sponsored by Senators Peter Brunstetter (R-Forsyth) and Eleanor Kinnaird (D-Orange).
For starters, the underlying premise of creating a "benefit corporation" is that traditional corporations and companies don't benefit the public. This notion, of course, is ludicrous. As Francis DeLuca noted in the 2011 Bad Bill summary: "A lawful, profitable business, by its very existence, already 'benefits' society...A business, by making a profit, increases the wealth of society and hence the ability of individuals to find employment and increase their standard of living. They also provide products and services that make our lives better."
Moreover, upon reading SB 99 we discover how the state would evaluate whether or not a company is a "benefit corporation." According to the bill, "a benefit corporation shall have as one of its corporate purposes the creation of a general public benefit." The legislation defines "general public benefit" as: "A material positive impact on society and the environment, taken as a whole, as measured by a third-party standard." (Emphasis added.)
This passage provides a major clue suggesting that SB 99 seeks to enforce the activities of companies according to certain standards of environmental impact and sustainability measures. And who provides this "third-party standard?"
A non-profit group called "B-Lab" is the primary third-party evaluator of B-corporations. One of the perks of becoming a B-corporation is joining a network of other companies to take advantage of discounted services provided by other B-corporations (the list of members confirms B-Lab's mission of largely promoting "sustainability" measures). Over time, however, it would not be surprising if B-corporations begin to seek favored tax statuses as well.
Oh, by the way, B-Lab doesn't appear to provide "third-party" approval for B-corporations out of the goodness of their hearts. According to this New York Times article, it can run up to $25,000 for a corporation to join the membership rolls of B-corporations.
What a nice scam for the B-Lab folks: pressure state legislatures to enact laws recognizing B-corporations based upon your approval, then charge for that approval.
If companies want to adjust how they spend their money or their "environmental impact," they should be free to do so and free to contract with consultants to evaluate and improve their efforts. There is no reason why legislation needs to interject itself into this process. It doesn't seem far-fetched to believe that this scheme was cooked up by B-Lab as an effort to use legislative authority to line their pockets. One also should be concerned with the use of legislative muscle to advance often highly questionable "sustainability" measures, as well as the potential for B-corporations to seek government privileges in the future. For these reasons, SB 99 is this week's Bad Bill of the Week.
| Dear Commissioners, March 12, 2013 | Civitas Institute, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics | John Droz, Jr.: A Most Important Energy / Environmental Message |
Latest Op-Ed & Politics
 |
'Kids should learn from mistakes, now they die – it can take one mistake'
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 10:16 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
 |
Daily Wire Editor Emeritus Ben Shapiro, along with hosts Matt Walsh, Andrew Klavan, and company co-founder Jeremy Boreing discussed the state of the 2024 presidential election before President Joe Biden gave his State of the Union address on Thursday.
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 10:07 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
 |
North Carolina has been declared free of “bird flu” by the World Organization for Animal Health after a dairy herd in North Carolina tested positive for the Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza, or “H5N1” as it is better known, earlier this year.
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 9:51 pm
By: Carolina Journal
|
 |
Pichai said the company is not to be used as a "personal platform" or to "debate politics"
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 9:47 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
 |
Military recruitment down
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 9:43 pm
By: Countrygirl1411
|
 |
Alcohol and driving
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 9:41 pm
By: Countrygirl1411
|
 |
Maryland Transportation Secretary Paul Wiedefeld said Tuesday morning that eight people were on the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore when a container ship rammed into one of its supports, causing the bridge to collapse into the frigid Patapsco River below.
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 9:36 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
 |
Whether he's putting on a beanie and pretending to be a gym rat or putting on a false nose and glasses and pretending to be gay, James O'Keefe is a true master of disguise.
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 9:22 pm
By: Babylon Bee
|
 |
President Joe Biden embellished details while telling a story about the disappearance of his uncle during World War II, suggesting that he had been eaten by “cannibals” after getting “shot down” in Papua New Guinea.
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 6:30 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
 |
Is it not obvious that the dumb rules are not improving the environment, except the bank accounts of the rich
|
 |
Florida Senator Marco Rubio warned President Biden not to accept mass migration from Haiti, saying, “the job of elected officials is to protect their citizens first, not anyone else’s.”
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 6:29 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
 |
as polls show majority of German people do not want any more Muslims
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 5:47 pm
By: John Steed
|
 |
Obama promised this would never happen; now his ex-VP does it
Published: Saturday, May 4th, 2024 @ 10:07 am
By: John Steed
|
 |
join Italy and Hungary which have banned it in Europe
Published: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 @ 9:15 pm
By: John Steed
|
 |
Victor Davis Hanson explains why higher education in America is on the skids
Published: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 @ 8:37 am
By: Beaufort Observer Editorial Team
|
 |
illegal alien "asylum seeker" migrants are a crime wave on both sides of the Atlantic
Published: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 @ 8:19 am
By: John Steed
|
 |
more ites between Biden White House and Alvin Bragg prosecution
Published: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 @ 7:47 am
By: John Steed
|
 |
open borders advocates proven wrong again
Published: Thursday, May 2nd, 2024 @ 1:39 pm
By: John Steed
|
Home
Contact
About
Service Rates
Privacy Policy
Follow on Facebook
Subscribe to Newsletters
Rss Feed
Keywords
Eastern NC Now & ENC NOW © Copyright 1998-2024 All Rights Reserved.
